A Draft That Divides: Vikings’ 2025 Haul Under the Microscope
The 2025 NFL Draft is in the books, and for Minnesota Vikings fans, it’s a tale of cautious optimism and fiery debate. On the latest episode of Skoldiers & Spice, host Sal Spice, joined by guest Eric Thompson, delivers a lively breakdown of the Vikings’ draft class, a blockbuster trade for quarterback Sam Howell, and a contract extension that has fans buzzing. Aired on the Vikings 1st & SKOL YouTube channel as part of the Fans First Sports Network, this episode captures the pulse of a fanbase grappling with a draft that prioritized practicality over flash. From the selection of Ohio State’s Donovan Jackson to the unexpected pick of Maryland’s Tai Felton, Sal and Eric navigate the highs and lows, offering insights that resonate with diehard SKOL chant enthusiasts.
“The draft is over and done with. We’ve got it in our rearview mirror, and reactions to the Vikings’ draft are all over the place,” Sal Spice declares at the episode’s outset, setting the stage for a candid discussion. With only four picks entering the draft, General Manager Kwesi Adofo-Mensah turned them into five, plus acquired Howell, a move that has shifted the conversation around the team’s quarterback depth. Add in the extension of edge rusher Andrew Van Ginkel, and it’s clear the Vikings are building methodically for 2025.
Donovan Jackson: The “Socks and Underwear” Pick
The Vikings’ first-round selection at No. 24, Ohio State offensive lineman Donovan Jackson, was the draft’s defining moment for Minnesota. While not the “blockbuster” pick some fans craved, Jackson’s selection addressed a glaring need for interior line stability. Eric Thompson praises the pick, noting its long-term value: “The socks and underwear analogy is perfect. No one loves an offensive lineman draft pick in April, but you really appreciate it in January [especially in February].”
Sal echoes this sentiment, reflecting on the team’s strategy to protect franchise quarterback J.J. McCarthy, who is recovering from a 2024 knee injury. “You gotta respect Kwesi and KOC [head coach Kevin O’Connell] prioritizing protecting their young quarterback,” she says. “He’s your long-term investment. He is your franchise guy.” Jackson, a versatile guard who also played left tackle during Ohio State’s national championship run, brings a bruising presence to an offensive line that struggled against top defenses like the Detroit Lions and Los Angeles Rams in 2024.
However, the lack of a trade-back in the first round surprised both hosts. With safeties and cornerbacks like Nick Emmanwori still available, some fans hoped for a splashier pick. “It’s kind of like socks and underwear for Christmas,” Sal quips, quoting Jordan Reed. “You need it, but it’s just not that exciting.” Yet, the consensus is clear: Jackson’s addition, alongside tackles Brian O’Neill and Christian Darrisaw, could elevate the Vikings’ offensive line to top-five status, a feat not seen since the 2009 or 1998 seasons.
Sam Howell Trade: QB2 Debate Settled?
The episode’s biggest bombshell is the Vikings’ trade with the Seattle Seahawks, sending pick No. 142 for quarterback Sam Howell and pick No. 172. Howell, a 24-year-old former Washington Commanders starter with 4,115 career passing yards, 22 touchdowns, and 23 interceptions, arrives as a potential backup for McCarthy. Sal poses the burning question: “Does this mean that we can put the Vikings QB2 debate to rest? Finally, at last?”
Eric Thompson is optimistic but measured. “If Howell has to start for half the year or most of the year, the Vikings are probably screwed,” he admits. “But he’s got the reps, high volume, high experience.” Howell’s 2023 season with Washington was marred by 65 sacks and a 4-13 record, but Eric points out the Commanders’ dysfunction: “That entire team was an absolute train wreck. It wasn’t just Sam.”
Sal initially questioned the move, comparing it to the acquisition of Jaren Hall, which she felt was a wasted pick. “I was like, what is this for?” she recalls. However, after reflection, she sees Howell as a low-risk, high-reward project for O’Connell, who revitalized Sam Darnold in 2024. “There’s some hope to him,” Sal notes. “I can see the parallels maybe with Sam Darnold.” With McCarthy expected to start in 2025, Howell’s $1.1 million cap hit provides cost-effective insurance, potentially ending speculation about veteran options like Aaron Rodgers and trading for Kirk Cousins.
Tai Felton’s Polarizing Pick and Defensive Oversights
The Vikings’ third-round selection of Maryland wide receiver Tai Felton drew the most fan criticism, a topic Sal and Eric tackle head-on. “I’ve seen fans the most disappointed in this one,” Sal says, noting that many viewed wide receiver as a low-priority need given stars like Justin Jefferson and Jordan Addison. Felton, who had a standout game against the Minnesota Gophers at Huntington Bank Stadium, boasts elite athleticism, ranking in the 90th percentile for relative athletic score.
Eric draws parallels to Stefon Diggs, another Maryland receiver drafted in the middle rounds: “There’s so many similarities in the draft profile between he and Diggs.” However, Felton’s inconsistent hands at the catch point raise concerns. His immediate value may lie in special teams, addressing the Vikings’ need for a returner after Brandon Powell’s departure. “KOC seems like he was really excited about the guy,” Sal adds, referencing O’Connell’s enthusiasm.
The decision to bypass defensive backs, particularly with corners and safeties available, sparked debate. “That’s the one area I still have the most concern about, especially when it comes to depth,” Eric says, citing aging star Harrison Smith and a thin cornerback group beyond Mekhi Blackmon and Byron Murphy Jr. Sal agrees, suggesting the pick reflects confidence in Blackmon’s recovery. The oversight leaves fans uneasy, with hopes pinned on undrafted free agents like Tommi Hill of Nebraska, to bolster the secondary.
Andrew Van Ginkel’s Extension: A Defensive Anchor Stays
Breaking news during the episode thrilled fans: edge rusher Andrew Van Ginkel signed a contract extension through 2026, worth $23 million with $22.5 million guaranteed. “He’s gonna be with the Vikings through at least the 2026 season,” Sal announces. “Big pay bump for him.” Eric calls it a “great move,” noting that Van Ginkel’s $17.5 million annual average ranks him among the top 15-20 edge rushers, a fair valuation for his impact.
Van Ginkel’s pick-sixes and relentless play in 2024 made him a fan favorite. “Every Dolphins fan I interacted with said, ‘You’re gonna really like this guy,’” Eric recalls. “They were wrong because I absolutely loved him.” The extension secures a rotational edge rusher alongside Jonathan Greenard and Dallas Turner, ensuring defensive flexibility. Sal emphasizes the strategic timing: “You don’t wanna risk him hitting the open market next offseason. You might be paying him even more.”
Undrafted Gems and a Nod to Randy Moss’s Son
The Vikings signed 19 undrafted free agents, a haul that could yield roster contributors. Eric highlights Gophers quarterback Max Brosmer and Kansas tackle Logan Brown, while Sal notes cornerback Tommi Hill’s potential. “If recent history is any indication, don’t be surprised if multiple people from that list make the 53 or the practice squad,” Eric says, crediting Kwesi’s scouting acumen.
A sentimental storyline emerges with the Vikings inviting Montigo Moss, son of legend Randy Moss, to rookie camp. Playing at Maine, Montigo recorded over 1,000 yards and nine touchdowns in FCS competition. “It’s a long shot,” Sal admits, “but how cool would that be if he did get the camp invite?” Eric agrees, envisioning Randy Moss cheering from the sidelines, a nostalgic boost for fans.
J.J. McCarthy’s Mindset and the Road Ahead
J.J. McCarthy’s recovery and mental approach remain focal points. Sal shares his recent media comments, where he discussed thriving under pressure due to his ADHD diagnosis. “I thought it was really cool that he mentioned that,” she says, relating as someone with ADHD. “He believes that’s because of his ADHD, and it made a lot of sense.” Eric praises McCarthy’s poise: “He’s great on the mic. He says exactly what I want to hear as a fan.”
With McCarthy poised to start, the draft’s focus on offensive line protection and Howell’s addition signal a team tailoring its roster for his success. “The Vikings have built such a great roster around him,” Eric notes. “He doesn’t have to be the greatest thing since sliced bread right out of the gate.”
SKOLFest and Fan Engagement
The episode buzzes with fan interaction, from chat poems to travel plans for away games. Sal urges fans to attend SKOLFest, joking, “No excuses. Everybody better be at SKOLFest!” She also shares her dream of a home game on her September 28 birthday, calling it “the biggest tailgate of all time.” Eric eyes a potential Ireland game, while both hosts encourage fans to book flights immediately after the May 14 schedule release to snag affordable tickets.
Listen:
Watch:
A Draft That Sets the Stage
Skoldiers & Spice captures the Vikings’ 2025 draft as a pragmatic step toward contention. While Donovan Jackson’s selection lacks sizzle, it fortifies the trenches. Sam Howell’s arrival quells QB2 concerns, and Andrew Van Ginkel’s extension locks in a defensive cornerstone. Tai Felton’s pick may divide fans, but his upside hints at untapped potential. As Sal wraps up, her call to action resonates: “Make sure you like and subscribe. We gotta hit 6,000 subscribers before the schedule release on May 14th.”
For Vikings fans, this episode is a rallying cry. Tune in to Vikings 1st & SKOL on YouTube, join the SKOL community, and gear up for a 2025 season that could redefine Minnesota’s trajectory. As Eric puts it, “I’m okay with having a boring offseason because I’m really excited about the Vikings.” SKOL!
Join Us and Fan!
Guest Eric Thompson @eric_j_thompson joins Sal Spice @SalSpice on this episode of “Skoldiers & Spice” with Dave Stefano @Luft_Krigare producing this Vikings 1st & SKOL @Vikings1stSKOL show. We’re partnered with Fans First Sports Network @FansFirstSN and their NFL feed @FFSN_NFL. #SKOL #Vikings!
Share & Comment: